News Archives

NFL Insiders Ranks New York Giants Head Coach Tom Coughlin No. 5 Overall, Behind Andy Reid

August 29th, 2014 at 2:00 PM
By Dan Benton

New York Giants head coach Tom Coughlin has long been considered one of the top tier coaches in the NFL, and one would have expected that trend to continue earlier this week when NFL Insiders polled 30 league insiders in an effort to create a new rankings system. But for the Big Blue head coach, he failed to cracked the top tier, instead being ranked in the second tier at No. 5 overall.

And it comes with an additional catch. Not only does Coughlin fall below New England Patriots head coach Bill Belichick, Seattle Seahawks head coach Pete Carroll and New Orleans Saints head coach Sean Peyton, but he also falls below Kansas City Chiefs head coach Andy Reid, who was ranked No. 4 overall.

5. Tom Coughlin, New York Giants (1.73 average) Having two Super Bowl titles in the bank bought some insurance for Coughlin coming off a 7-9 season featuring an 0-6 start. There was some thinking that Coughlin, the NFL's oldest coach (he'll turn 68 on Sunday), had slipped from a 1 to a 2 in recent years, but that is difficult to know from afar. Coughlin drew high marks for taking Jacksonville to the AFC title game, then adjusting his old-school approach to help the Giants win two Super Bowls, one of them against an 18-0 New England team.

"He is every bit as solid as Belichick," said a former GM who placed Coughlin in the top tier. "He has done it over time and been very consistent. You can say he is old-school, but I think he appeals to young guys. He is very sound. Nothing falls through the cracks. These guys at the top, if I were with them, I would spend not a single minute worried about whether we were coached right or had everything covered."

It's possible to justify Belichick, Carroll and even Peyton ahead of Coughlin (although we, admittedly, wouldn't agree with that), but it's seems like an illogical argument to suggest Reid is an superior coach to Coughlin. If nothing else, at least the other three have Super Bowl rings. Ried, meanwhile, has a whole lot of nothing.

What say you, Giants fans? Where would you rank Tom Coughlin?


Seeing your team play in the SuperBowl is priceless. Watching the SuperBowl live in the stands for $1 per week is beyond priceless. Find out how at, the future of Championship Tickets. Tags: Andy Reid, Bill Belichick, Football, New York, New York Giants, NFL, Pete Carroll, Tom Coughlin

13 Responses to “NFL Insiders Ranks New York Giants Head Coach Tom Coughlin No. 5 Overall, Behind Andy Reid”

  1.  GOAT56 says:


    BBG – Robinson caught 2 seem passes which is as much as the other TEs combined. It isn’t much and Robinson hasn’t done enough to gain anyone’s confidence. But neither have any of the TEs. That 3rd down play Davis didn’t make yesterday makes him almost useless if he can’t make. None of the TEs have stood out. So like Nosh and F55 have also said since we don’t know anything let’s play the guy with the highest ceiling. I don’t see the issue. Davis certainly shouldn’t start or even be on the team IMO. If you want the safe start it’s clearly Fells.

  2.  Krow says:

    Well the end of pre-season means one thing for sure … no more of these dumba$$ lists.

    And seriously … are we arguing over which of these midgets is the tallest TE on the team? All any of them are going to do is make a few garbage catches … and that’s only because they’re so non-threatening that they’ll be the last thing any DC worries about.

  3.  NC Giant says:

    agree about the TE talk but just to add another log to the smoldering fire…I agree that you start the guy with the highest ceiling (albeit perhaps a ceiling in a midget’s home…hat tip Krow) which in my estimation is Robinson.

    Other topics:

    1. Redo this past April’s Draft Rounds 1-3 who would you have taken?

    2. Best FA signing this offseason so far

    3. More 2014 catches: Randle, Washington, or ODB?

    My answers:
    1. Zack Martin (T, G, C), Richburg (C), either Gabe Jackson (G) or Moncreif (WR)
    2. Jennings
    3. Randle (but it may be very close)

  4.  NC Giant says:

    Who could shake loose off another roster that we could find of value/interest? Anyone have some insight?

    Also…where is Smardjza (I know I did not spell that right)

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Login with: