News Archives

New York Giants May Receive at Least a 5th Round Compensatory Pick: Projections

February 9th, 2014 at 9:00 AM
By Dan Benton

Although no exact public formula exists for how the NFL determines compensatory picks, there is enough information available for the well-informed to make relatively accurate projections. And with a very sound resume, Craig Turner is essentially the expert compensatory pick projector. A year ago, he correctly projected picks for 24 teams, while only coming away entirely incorrect on three (which was credited to a "gray area"). As such, he get the benefit of the doubt.

mjpeacecorps / Foter / CC BY-NC

In his most recent projections for the 2014 NFL Draft, Turner has the New York Giants receiving, at the very least, one 5th round compensatory pick. However, depending on how the NFL views a few other variables, Big Blue may walk away with up to three compensatory picks.

Let's take a look, shall we?

Players lost: Martellus Bennett ($5.1M), Osi Umenyiora ($4.25M), Domenik Hixon ($1.2M) and Chase Blackburn ($1M).

Players signed: Brandon Myers ($3.6M), Josh Brown ($930K), Ryan Mundy ($780K) and Louis Murphy ($715K).

Now, this is where things get tricky for the Giants.

Because Umenyiora's contract was voidable a season ago and used to "push money" to future cap purposes, Turner did not reward the Giants for his loss. However, the NFL may not see it that way and could potentially reward the Giants for his departure to the Atlanta Falcons. This scenario however, is unlikely.

Turner also took away a potential 7th round compensatory pick for the Giants because Mundy played over 100 snaps (667 snaps). However, if the NFL deems Mundy unqualified for compensatory pick factoring, it would result in the Giants receiving the aforementioned 7th round pick.

Finally, because kicker Josh Brown did not play a full season for the Cincinnati Bengals in 2012/2013, Cincy is unlikely to receive a compensatory pick for his loss to the Giants.

Ultimately, with Brandon Myers' contract having been voided, the decision by General Manager Jerry Reese not to pay Martellus Bennett his asking price a season ago has resulted in little more than a 5th round compensatory pick.

Likely final scenario: Giants receive a 5th round compensatory pick.

Best case scenario: Giants receive 5th round and two 7th round compensatory picks.


Super Bowl XLVIII Contest Winner: Congratulations to Krow, who won the Sports Media 101 Super Bowl XLVIII contest. Please e-mail to claim your prize!


Just because the Super Bowl left NY/NJ it doesn't mean the NFL action is over. Come see the Gridiron Glory: The Best of the Pro Football Hall of Fame at Liberty Science Center see jerseys worn by legends, make the tough call under the hood, try on equipment and get immersed into football like never before.

Tags: Atlanta, Atlanta Falcons, Brandon Myers, Chase Blackburn, Cincinnati, Cincinnati Bengals, Domenik Hixon, Football, Jerry Reese, Martellus Bennett, New York, New York Giants, NFL, Osi Umenyiora, Ryan Mundy

12 Responses to “New York Giants May Receive at Least a 5th Round Compensatory Pick: Projections”

  1.  Dirt says:

    With the 16th pick in the 5th round of the 2014 NFL Draft, the New York Giants select Turd Ferguson, quarterback, directional Michigan junior college.

  2.  Hanshi says:

    Congrats to Krow!

  3.  Hanshi says:

    I just read this.
    Last February Kiper had Damontre Moore going No. 2 overall to the Jacksonville Jaguars. Moore went No. 81 to the Giants in Round 3. Yet, he was the most accurate at this time a year ago.

  4.  Dirt says:

    I happen to think Jerry Reese couldn’t hold Ernie Accorsi’s jock. A couple of examples:

    - No way Reese takes “the risk” to trade for Eli Manning in 2004. Instead he sticks to his board and takes Rapistberger or Rivers (or some project athlete at some other skill position).

    - In 2005-2006, with said QB, Accorsi goes and gets all the impact players he can to put the QB in a position to succeed. He signs ready made men like McKenzie, O’Hara, Burress, with the intention of keeping them for the long term. He spends a high pick on a highly touted interior lineman in Snee. Reese would have been in the dumpster looking for eclairs and signing guys to 1 year show me deals, or drafting projects who needed time to acclimate theselves. (Not to mention key signings on the defensive side, such as Pierce, Robbins)

    That’s not to say Reese has been all bad. Nicks, Smith, JPP, Rolle, Beason come to mind. But I don’t think he would have constructed a winner without the foundation laid by Accorsi, and I don’t think he would have come anywhere close to that foundation on his own.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Login with: